Switch branches/tags
Nothing to show
Latest commit 2196504 Oct 18, 2017 @lukedemi lukedemi Merge pull request #151 from lukedemi/luke/vpn_connection_route
fix vpn_connection_route remote resource fetching




GeoEngineer provides a Ruby DSL and command line tool (geo) to codify then plan and execute changes to cloud resources.

GeoEngineer's goals/requirements/features are:

  1. DSL based on Terraform: GeoEngineer uses Terraform to plan and execute changes, so the DSL to describe resources is similar to Terraform's. GeoEngineer's DSL also provides programming and object oriented features like inheritance, abstraction, branching and looping.
  2. Development Workflow: GeoEngineer is built to be used within existing development workflows, e.g. branching, creating pull requests, code reviewing and merging. To simplify these workflows, GeoEngineer dynamically generates Terraform state files using cloud APIs and opinionated tagging.
  3. Extensible Validation: Every team has their own standards when managing cloud resources e.g. naming patterns, tagging requirements, security rules. GeoEngineer resources can have custom validations added to ensure the resources conform to required standards.
  4. Reusable Templates: copy and pasting codified resources makes it difficult to understand and maintain infrastructure. By abstracting recommended patterns of reuse into templates, GeoEngineer aims to increase code reuse and decrease code copy/paste.
  5. Describe Existing Resources: Existing resources can be described with GeoEngineer without having to destroy and recreate them.
  6. Principle of Least Astonishment: show the exact plan before execution; do nothing without confirmation; do not allow a plan to be executed with failing validations; by default do not allow deletions; show warnings and hints to make code better.
  7. One File per Project: Managing dozens of projects with hundreds of files is difficult and error-prone, especially if a single project's resources are described across many files. Projects are easier to manage when they are each described in one file.
  8. Dependencies: resources have dependencies on other resources, projects have dependencies on other projects. Using Ruby's require file that describe resources can be included and referenced without having to hard-code any values.

Getting Started

Install Terraform

Instructions to install Terraform can be found here.

Install Ruby

Instructions to install Ruby can be found here.

Install GeoEngineer

Secure install (this will validate the geoengineer gem):

gem cert --add <(curl -Ls
gem install geoengineer --trust-policy MediumSecurity

Note: HighSecurity will not work because aws-sdk and other gems are not signed

Or just install normally:

gem install geoengineer

Test it is installed correctly with:

geo --help

First GeoEngineer Project

GeoEngineer can use the folder structure where projects and environments are in the projects and environments directories respectively, however everything can also be defined in a single file, e.g. first_project.rb:

# First define the environment which is available with the variable `env`
# This is where project invariants are stored, e.g. subnets, vpc ...
environment("staging") {
  account_id  "1"
  subnet      "1"
  vpc_id      "1"
  allow_destroy true ## Defaults to false.  Set to true to support `geo destroy ...`

# Create the first_project to be in the `staging` environment
project = project('org', 'first_project') {
  environments 'staging'

# Define the security group for the ELB to allow HTTP
elb_sg = project.resource("aws_security_group", "allow_http") {
  name         "allow_http"
  description  "Allow All HTTP"
  vpc_id       env.vpc_id
  ingress {
      from_port    80
      to_port      80
      protocol     "tcp"
      cidr_blocks  [""]
  tags {
    Name "allow_http"

# Define the security group for EC2 to allow ingress from the ELB
ec2_sg = project.resource("aws_security_group", "allow_elb") {
  name         "allow_elb"
  description  "Allow ELB to 80"
  vpc_id       env.vpc_id
  ingress {
      from_port    8000
      to_port      8000
      protocol     "tcp"
      security_groups  [elb_sg]
  tags {
    Name "allow_elb"

# cloud_config to run webserver
user_data = %{
  - docker run -d --name nginx -p 8000:80 nginx

# Create an EC2 instance to run nginx server
instance = project.resource("aws_instance", "web") {
  ami           "ami-1c94e10b" # COREOS AMI
  instance_type "t1.micro"
  subnet_id     env.subnet
  user_data     user_data
  tags {
    Name "ec2_instance"

# Create the ELB connected to the instance
project.resource("aws_elb", "main-web-app") {
  name             "main-app-elb"
  security_groups  [elb_sg]
  subnets          [env.subnet]
  instances        [instance]
  listener {
    instance_port     8000
    instance_protocol "http"
    lb_port           80
    lb_protocol       "http"

GeoEngineer command line tool geo can:

  1. Create a plan with geo plan -e staging first_project.rb
  2. Execute the plan with geo apply -e staging first_project.rb
  3. Create a graph with geo graph -e staging --quiet first_project.rb | dot -Tpng > graph.png && open graph.png
  4. Status of Codeified Resources with geo status first_project.rb -e staging

There are more examples in the examples folder.


A core benefit of GeoEngineer is the ability to customize the DSL to your needs using custom validations, templates and reusable methods on resources.


Below is an example which will add the validation to ensure that all listeners on all ELB's must be HTTPS, for security reasons.

class GeoEngineer::Resources::AwsElb < GeoEngineer::Resource
  validate :validate_listeners_must_be_https

  def validate_listeners_must_be_https
    errors = []{ |i| i.lb_protocol != 'https' }.each do
      errors << "ELB must use https protocol #{for_resource}"
    return errors


Below is an example template that builds a Elastic Load Balancer and a security group for an array of listeners:

class LoadBalancedInstance < Template
  attr_reader :elb, :elb_sg

  def initialize(name, project, parameters)
    super(name, project, parameters)
    # { listeners: [{ in: out: }]}
    listeners = parameters[:listeners] || []

    # Create the Security Groups
    elb_sg = resource("aws_security_group", "#{name}_allow_http") {
      name         "#{name}_elb_sg"
      description  ""
      vpc_id       env.vpc_id
      for l in listeners
        ingress {
          from_port    l[:in]
          to_port      l[:in]
          protocol     "tcp"
          cidr_blocks  [""]
      tags { Name "#{name}_elb_sg" }

    # ELB
    elb = resource("aws_elb", "main-web-app") {
      name             "#{name}_elb"
      security_groups  [elb_sg]
      subnets          [env.subnet]
      for l in listeners
        listener {
          instance_port     l[:out]
          instance_protocol "http"
          lb_port           l[:in]
          lb_protocol       "http"

    @elb    = elb
    @elb_sg = elb_sg

  def template_resources
    [@elb, @elb_sg]

# Instantiate the template for this project to forward two ports 80 and 8080
project.from_template("load_balanced_instance", "main_app", {
  listeners: [{in: 80, out: 3000 }, {in: 8080, out: 4000 }]


Define methods to be used in your own resources, e.g. a custom method to security group to add a rule:

class GeoEngineer::Resources::AwsSecurityGroup < GeoEngineer::Resource
  # ...
  def all_egress_everywhere
    egress {
        from_port        0
        to_port          0
        protocol         "-1"
        cidr_blocks      [""]
  # ...

project.resource('aws_security_group', 'all_egress') {
  all_egress_everywhere # use the method to add egress

Adding New Resources

The best way to contribute is to add resources that exist in Terraform but are not yet described in GeoEngineer.

To define a resource:

  1. checkout and fork/branch GeoEngineer
  2. create a file ./lib/geoengineer/resources/<resource_type>.rb
  3. define a class class GeoEngineer::Resources::<ResourceType> < GeoEngineer::Resource
  4. define _terraform_id, and potentially _geo_id and self._fetch_remote_resources method (more below).
  5. write a test file for the resource that follows the style of other similar resources

Codeified to Remote Resources

A fundamental problem with codifying resources is matching the in code resource to the real remote resource. Terraform does this by maintaining an id in a state file which is matched to a remote resources attribute. This attribute is different per resource, e.g. for ELB's it is their name, for security groups it is their group_name that is generated so cannot be codified.

Without a state file GeoEngineer uses API's to match resources, this makes generated id's likes security groups difficult. For these generated ids GeoEngineer uses tags e.g. for ELB's the GeoEngineer id is its name (just like Terraform) and for security groups it is their Name tag.

In a GeoEngineer resource the _terraform_id is the id used by Terraform and the _geo_id is GeoEngineer ID. By default a resources _geo_id is the same as the _terraform_id, so for most resources only the _terraform_id is required.

If _terraform_id is generated then the remote resource needed to be fetched via API and matched to the codified resource with _geo_id. This is done by implementing the self._fetch_remote_resources method to use the API and return a list of resources with both _terraform_id and _geo_id, then GeoEngineer can match them.

For example, in aws_security_group's the resource is matched based on the Name tag, implements as:

class GeoEngineer::Resources::AwsSecurityGroup < GeoEngineer::Resource
  after :initialize, -> { _terraform_id -> { NullObject.maybe(remote_resource)._terraform_id } }
  after :initialize, -> { _geo_id -> { NullObject.maybe(tags)[:Name] } }

  def self._fetch_remote_resources(provider)
      .map(&:to_h).map do |sg|
        sg[:name] = sg[:group_name]
        sg[:_terraform_id] = sg[:group_id]
        sg[:_geo_id] = sg[:tags] ? sg[:tags].select { |x| x[:key] == "Name" }.first[:value] : nil


Terraform does not validate a lot of attributes before they are sent to the cloud. This means that often plans will fail for reasons that could have been initially validated. When creating a resource think about what validations could be done to ensure a plan is successful.

For example, a security groups needs a Name tag, requires a name and description, and a more complicated example is that its cidr_blocks should be valid:

class GeoEngineer::Resources::AwsSecurityGroup < GeoEngineer::Resource
  # ...
  validate :validate_correct_cidr_blocks
  validate -> { validate_required_attributes([:name, :description]) }
  validate -> { validate_has_tag(:Name) }

  def validate_correct_cidr_blocks
    errors = []
    (self.all_ingress + self.all_egress).each do |in_eg|
      next unless in_eg.cidr_blocks
      in_eg.cidr_blocks.each do |cidr|
        rescue NetAddr::ValidationError
          errors << "Bad cidr block \"#{cidr}\" #{for_resource}"
  # ...

Terraform State

Terraform by default will attempt to sync its resources with the API so that its state file is up to date with the real world. Given that GeoEngineer uses Terraform in a different way this sometimes causes plans to list changes that have already happened.

To fix this issue a resource can override to_terraform_state method, e.g. aws_db_instance has issues with final_snapshot_identifier updating:

class GeoEngineer::Resources::AwsDbInstance < GeoEngineer::Resource
  # ...
  def to_terraform_state
    tfstate = super
    tfstate[:primary][:attributes] = {
      'final_snapshot_identifier' => final_snapshot_identifier,
  # ...

GeoEngineer Reference

The core models in GeoEngineer are:

 +-------------+ 1
 | Environment +-----------+
 +-------------+           |
       | 1                 |
       |                   |
       v *                 v *
 +-----+-------+ 1  * +-------------+ 1  *  +-------------+
 | Project     +----->+ Resource    +------>+ SubResource |
 +-------------+      +-------------+       +-------------+
       | 1                 ^ *
       |                   |
       v *                 |
 +-------------+           |
 | Template    +-----------+
 +-------------+ 1
  1. Environment contains many resources that may exist outside of a project, like VPCs or routing tables. Also every project defined to be in the environment, for example the test_www project is in staging but monorail is in staging and production environments.
  2. Project contains many resources and services grouped together into a name.
  3. Template has a type and name, and a group of resources that are defined in a pattern, e.g. every Load Balancer requires a unique security group that allows traffic in. It is a simple abstraction that can dramatically simplify and standardize cloud resources.
  4. Resource and SubResource are based off of how terraform models cloud resources. A Resource instance can have many SubResource instances, but a SubResource instance belongs to only one Resource instance, e.g. a load balancer resource may have a health_check sub-resource to only allow specific incoming ports.

All these models can have arbitrary attributes assigned to them either by directly assigning on the instance, or through passing a block to the constructor. For example:

resource ='type','id') { |res|
  res.hello = 'hey'
  puts res.hello # 'hey'
  hello 'hey again' #
  puts res.hello # 'hey again'

  # INCORRECT way of assigning variables
  goodbye = 'nooo' # This assigns a local variable, not an attribute on the resource
  puts res.goodbye # nil

puts resource.hello # 'hey again'

resource.goodbye = 'see ya'
puts resource.goodbye # 'see ya'

Additionally, if the value is expensive to calculate or requires other attributes not yet assigned, an attribute can be assigned a Proc or lambda which will be calculated lazily:

resource ='type','id')
resource.lazy_attr = -> { puts "CALCULATING THE VALUE"; 'value' }
# ...
puts resource.lazy_attr
#$ "value"


The top level class in GeoEngineer is the environment: it contains all projects, resources and services, and there should only ever be one initialized at a time.

An environment can mean many things to different people, e.g. an AWS account, an AWS region, or a specific AWS VPC. The only real constraint is that a resource has one instance per environment, e.g. a load balancer that is defined to be in staging and production environments, will have an instance in each.

The function environment is provided as a factory to build an environment:

environment = environment("environment_name") { |e|
  e.attr_1 = [1,2,3]
  attr_2 'value'
environment.attr_3 = "another value"


A project is a group of resources typically provisioned to deploy one code base. A project has an organization and name, to mimic the github username/organiztion and repository structure.

A project is defined like:

project = project('org', 'project_name') {
  environments 'staging', 'production'

This projects organization is org, its name project_name and will be provisioned in the staging and production environments. The org and name must be unique across all other projects.

The method project will automatically add the project to the instantiated environment object only if that environment's name is in the list of environments, otherwise it is ignored.


A template is used to create a group of resources in a recommended pattern. For example, an HTTP service could create a load balancer, a load balancer security group, and a ec2 security group.

template_instance = project.from_template('template_type', 'name', parameter: 'helloworld') { |resource, resource_sg|

  # set attribute
  attribute "custom attribute"

  # Customize the values
  resource.cutomize_value = "Customize"
  resource.override_value = "Override"

  # Overrider a subresource value
  resource.subresource.override_sr_value = "first value"
  resource.all_subresource[1].override_sr_value = "new value"

template_instance.resource_sg # access the created resources outside the block

This template will create a resource resource and a resource security group resource_sg with the option hello set to value 'world'. The resources can then be customized and have their values overridden.

Each template should be documented with the created resources and how to modify them.

Resources and SubResources

Resources are defined to be similar to the terraform resource configuration. The main difference is to not use = as this will create a local ruby variable and not assign the value.

A Resource can be created with and environment, project or template object (this will add that resource to that object):

environment.resource('type', 'identifier') {
  name "resource_name"
  subresource {
    attribute "attribute"

project.resource('type', 'identifier') {
  # ...

template.resource('type', 'identifier') {
  # ...

The type of a resource must be a valid terraform type, where AWS types are listed here. Some resources are not supported yet by GeoEngineer.

identifier is used by GeoEngineer and terraform to reference this resource must be unique, however it is not stored in the cloud so can be changed without affecting a plan.

A resource also has a ruby block sent to it that contains parameters and sub-resources. These values are defined by terraform so for reference to what values are required please refer to the terraform docs.